Order
Order online and schedule a day for pickup.
Fall Menu
Pies, Cakes, Cookies and treats for a cozy, sweet season!
Pie
Flaky, homemade crusts with fruits and fillings to warm you on crisp fall days
Heritage Apple
Buttery, hand rolled crust with fluted edge, sweet autumn apples and spices, topped with a French crumble top
$35.00
Apple Pecan with Bourbon Caramel
A boozy twist on a classic apple. Apples perfectly seasoned with taste of fall, crowned with pecans, and bathed in a bourbon whisky caramel
$40.00
Mixed Berry
Blueberries, blackberries and raspberries baked together in a heavenly handmade crust and crowned with a buttery crumble top. A Sweet Gertrude signature pie.
$35.00
All American Cherry
Tart cherries in a fluted, hand rolled crust, and crowned with a sparkling lattice top. Sometimes the simple classics are the best.
$35.00
Classic Blueberry
Blueberries, bursting with flavor between two hand rolled butter crusts, are brightened with a hint of lemon
$35.00
Joe's Old Fashioned Pecan
A rich sweet pie steeped in tradition with southern pecans, vanilla and cinnamon in a single buttery crust.
$40.00
Bread
Sweet and savory breads, biscuits and rolls to grace your autumn harvest table
Focaccia
Golden brown crust drizzled with olive oil, bubbles throughout the dough create and airy, tender chew. Finished with sea salt.
$25.00
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Loaf
For the pumpkin spice lover, this is the taste of the season. The flavor of pumpkin pie and semi-sweet chocolate chips combine for a seasonal favorite that's hard to put down.
$15.00
Cookies
Buttery, sweet goodness. All cookies priced by the dozen
Chocolate Chip
Browned butter adds delicious depth to the simple chocolate chip cookie. A crisp edge and soft center, semi-sweet chocolate chips and a light sprinkle of sea salt make these a melt in your mouth indulgence.
$24.00
Autumn Molasses Marshmallow
Chewy molasses cookies with just the right amount of warm spices, blended with soft, homemade marshmallow.
$24.00
Chocolate Charmers
All chocolate cookie with a crisp and crackled exterior. Soft, chewy and chocolatey. Adorned with a sparkly sugar top.
$24.00
Elizabeths
Delicate, soft and simple, the Elizabeth is a butter and vanilla cookie with an unexpected subtle tang that comes from rich cream cheese.
$24.00
Cakes
Old-fashioned cakes with wholesome ingredients like your grandma used to make. Our cakes make any day a special occasion.
THE Chocolate Cake
Our most requested cake. Two moist chocolate layers adorned with a soft, whipped vanilla frosting that's extra fluffy. Serves 10.
$40.00
Tavern Cake
Warm spices, molasses, dark brown sugar, and Guinness stout make this Bundt cake a must for the serious gingerbread lover. Add your own dollop of cream for a heavenly holiday experience.
$40.00
Salted Caramel Chocolate Cake
3 layers of dark chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream icing and layers of gooey salted caramel.
$50.00
Pumpkin Cake
Flavorful pumpkin and spices make up two moist layers frosted in a tangy cream cheese frosting.
$40.00